« Carol Shea-Porter: My favorite Fourth of July Pictures | Main | The Shake Up in John McCain's Campaign »

Guest Piece By Kathy Sullivan: Sununu Front Group Attacks Shaheen in NH

Kathy wrote this for the Huffington Post. I've seen these ads and its important to understand the murky back story behind "Americans For Job Security."

 

As the 2008 election draws ever closer, New Hampshire voters will be seeing lots of political activity. Former Governor Jeanne Shaheen has been out talking to voters and running positive television ads describing the issues she will champion in the United States Senate, such as reducing gas prices, fixing the economy and brining our troops home from Iraq. Unfortunately, Republican operatives, hiding behind a front group named Americans for Job Security, have already spent over $250,000 attacking Shaheen on radio and in the mail, and they're employing the same sort of behavior that has prompted outrage among New Hampshire voters in the past. Shaheen is the top target for Republican attacks this year, and she'll need as much help as possible in responding: www.jeanneshaheen.org .

AJS is a non-profit organization that claims to be a trade association, yet according to a 2004 Washington Monthly story, it does not list its members. While political committees and candidates by law must disclose their contributors, groups like AJS pretend that they are engaging in "issues advocacy", educating the public. But a 2004 Texas Observer article (appropriate entitled "Meet the Attack Dogs") called AJS what it really is: "one of the nation's most vicious campaign hit teams, a secret outfit whose reach spreads all over the American political system. It specializes in attempted assassination of political careers under the guise of issue education...."

Furthermore, to qualify as an issues group, AJS must be independent of any campaign or candidate. Yet AJS has a long record of running attack ads in election years in states from Alaska to Texas to Minnesota to New Hampshire, and has a history of connections to the Sununu family and Republican politics. In 2002, for example, it ran over $1 million in anti-Shaheen ads. Its executive director at the time was longtime Sununu family confidante David Carney, who previously had run the draft Sununu effort. Benjamin Ginsburg, the attorney for the infamous Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, served as legal counsel to AJS. Former NHGOP executive director Steve DeMaura currently runs AJS.

AJS and people associated with AJS have a history voters should be aware of. For example, according to a report by the New Hampshire Attorney General, in 2002 Republican operatives discussed forming a committee to make "independent expenditures" in that year's primary elections. I stress the term "independent expenditure" because under the law, independent expenditures cannot be coordinated with candidates or their agents. One operative was quoted in the report stating that David Carney, at the time an aide to Republican gubernatorial candidate Gordon Humphey, told the others he could get $10,000 from the Republican Gubernatorial Association to help pay for calls encouraging Democratic voters to vote for Governor Shaheen's primary opponent. That plan did not go forward, but Carney was forced to apologize for baselessly accusing Governor Shaheen's campaign of anonymous telephone and postcard attacks on Humphrey, which were in fact arranged by Republicans.

In 2004, Norway Hill, a company owned by Carney, paid workers to obtain petition signature to put independent presidential candidate Ralph Nader's name on the Granite State ballot. When asked by reporters about the effort, Carney claimed that Norway Hill had undertaken the effort at the behest of a group called "Choices for America", and that Norway Hill's activities were a donation to Choices for America. However, Choices for America representatives told Federal Elections Commission investigators that they had no knowledge of Norway Hill. The investigators concluded that Norway Hill had made a prohibited in kind corporate contribution to assist the Nader campaign. Unfortunately, the FEC commissioners stunningly decided to turn a blind eye to its own investigators' recommendations, letting Norway Hill off the hook following individual $2,000 payments made by Carney, his wife and a business associate to Norway Hill, and reported the payments as donations to the Nader campaign.

AJS itself has been the subject of several investigations. Last year, Public Citizen, a campaign finance watchdog group, filed complaints with both the FEC and the IRS against AJS. In 2002, the Alaska Public Offices Commission ruled that AJS violated state campaign laws. In 2004, AJS paid fines in Oklahoma for violating the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (there they go with phones again!). And last week, the New Hampshire Democratic Party filed a complaint with the FEC because the AJS radio ads against Shaheen violate federal election law.

So, here we are, in 2008, and Americans for Job Security is running attack ads against a political candidate during an election year, yet claiming that it is not trying to influence an election, and refusing to release the names of its members or its donors. The difference this year is that New Hampshire voters have shown that they are tired of Republican operatives and organizations that refuse to play by the rules. The 2002 phone jamming conspiracy nearly bankrupted the state Republican Party. The harassing phone calls made by the National Republican Congressional Caucus in 2006 were the final nail in the coffin of Charlie Bass's failed re-election bid. It is time for the New Hampshire Republican Party and Republican candidates like John E. Sununu to show New Hampshire voters that they have learned their lesson, and that they reject the tired old tactics of past campaigns. They can do that by demanding that AJS disclose who its members are, where its money comes from, and that it stop its attack ads.

Posted on Thursday, July 3, 2008 at 09:07PM by Registered CommenterChaz Proulx | Comments12 Comments

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (12)

With the Democrats, if it ain't pedophiles, it's people who enable voter fraud crime.
July 3, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterObserver
Observer

I'm not sure what your point is. Happy to respond if you want to clarify for me

Thanks
July 4, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterChaz Proulx
Blah Blah Blah. The Democrats can dish it out, but when the GOP gives it back, they cry foul. What cynicism! What hypocrisy!

Hundreds of millions of dollars will be spent on behalf of Obama and other Dems this year by 527s, big unions, and other special interest groups. They're no different than AJS.

The truth is that AJS has hit a nerve with the Shaheen camp. Shaheen knows she can't debate the facts so she sends her attact dogs out to attact the messanger. It's from chapter one in the Bill Clinton playbook. Remember how he attacked the integrity of Monica, Paula et al? It was working until a little stain showed up on a blue dress.
July 4, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterBigdog
Where's Billy Boy Shaheen in all this? Shouldn't he be out attacking his wife's critics? Can't he accuse them of dealing drugs?
July 4, 2008 | Unregistered Commentercapitalcat
Re: voter fraud: wasn't Kathy Sullivan, (as Dem state party chair), letting out-of-staters use her address so they could vote in NH?
July 7, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJohn D.
Dear Chaz,

It does strike me as odd that Ms. Sullivan would be squeamish about front groups or even behind-the-scenes groups: political operatives from both parties do fairly nefarious deeds in order to impugn opponents. There is nothing noble about the process; there is nothing even particularly noble about a Democratic party campaign vis-รก-vis a Republican one. Your party is quite guilty of abusing the reputations and characters of its opponents; surely Ms. Sullivan knows this. Egads, she has posted her thoughts at the Huffington Post. Philosophers the world over do NOT gather at the HuffPo for examples of pellucid attack-free commentary. Ad hominems are de rigeur at that site (and many similar media and p.r. outlets).

One need only recall the vicious insinuations tossed out to the public via the Clinton campaign regarding Mr. Obama; and Wesley Clark's recent absurdities regarding Mr. McCain's lack of military leadership qualities despite his actual experiences were not offered on mere whim: they were intended to impugn, and no greater proof of this is that a major news outlet was interviewing the nobody that is Wesley Clark. People, especially second- and third-tier folks like Clark, don't just get to appear on a Sunday news program by dropping a line or a dime. Clark was sent; he served as proxy for the Obama campaign.

My reply to Kathy Sullivan is simple: Welcome to reality, Ms. Sullivan. Welcome to American politics. But if, Ms. Sullivan, you are only now getting around to noticing the obvious, then you are naive, and carry very little gravitas. But if you have always noticed the truth and yet are only now averring a distaste for this great game, then I should think you are being disingenuous.

(Full disclosure: I have been hired several times to work as a photographer by Norway Hill Associates; the Carneys are essentially my neighbors. This relation has nothing to do with ideology; I have also worked as a photographer for the Dick Swett campaign. Swett was a Bow Democrat.)

Peace,

Bill Gnade


July 7, 2008 | Registered CommenterBill Gnade
Bill

You left out the main point--with AJS there are legal issues that the NHDP is now testing.

AJS has already been found guilty in one state--Oklahoma.

Now we'll see what the FEC thinks of their NH operation.

Its the Republican party that has a history of stepping over the line in NH.









July 7, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterChaz Proulx
Wow - you mean to tell us that people from "out of state" are coming in here and messing with OUR Senate race? Good golly, I never heard of such a thing! Of course there are no outside groups funding Shaheen and of course there will never be any "attack" ads against Sununu now will there? Get over it Chaz - it's called free speech. You should be thankful we still have it. I am sure if we traced every dollar of Shaheen contributions we could write an equally interesting diatribe. Issue advocacy is the new way to get involved in the political process, thanks to campaign finance "reform". Someone starts organization called "Americans for Mom, apple pie, and comfortable shoes", organization gets funding from right or left wing well known sources, organization runs attack ads, rinse, repeat. Big deal. Get over it.
July 7, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterConcerned Taxpayer
Concerned Taxpayer

With all due respect, you, like Bill Gnade aboce you missed the BIG point here.

There are legal limits to 501 c's etc. The Federal Elections Commission will decide the fate of AJS now that the New Hampshire Democratic Party has filed a complaing.

And yes ( I agree) if the Republicans filed a complaint against say "Move on" then the FEC would decide that.

I have never claimed that out of state "issue advocacy groups" are the sole province of either the right or the left.

But these groups are subject to regulation.

July 7, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterChaz Proulx
oops--I mangled a sentence.

should have read:

With all due respect, you (like Bill Gnade above ) missed the BIG point here.
July 7, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterChaz Proulx
Dear Chaz,

I have not suggested that the Republicans have not been doing anything illegal; or, I should say, that SOME Republicans have not been doing anything illegal in NH. But I think you can only justifiably report that a few Republicans are the only ones who have been CAUGHT doing illegal things.

If you believe that there are no cheaters in the Democratic Party doing nefarious deeds in a variety of state elections, I find your credulity incredible. But I don't believe you are that credulous. In fact, I KNOW you're not.

BG
July 8, 2008 | Registered CommenterBill Gnade
Bill

Yeah sure, whatever you say

by the way--Do you know who Kathy Sullivan is?

July 8, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterChaz Proulx

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.